Jump to content

Miley Cyrus, Stop Disrespecting What 'Feels Black'


Escapade
 Share

Recommended Posts

Dear Ms. Miley Cyrus,

Growing up, I was a huge fan of your hit television show Hannah Montana and some of the catchy songs you performed on the Disney Channel. Most of the themes reflected in your music revealed the life you lived as a teen in Hollywood with privilege and excess.

Being then a young black middle-class teenager, I never found the dichotomy to be a barrier between me as the fan and you as the celebrity. I found your personality to be entertaining and respected that you were being yourself and singing about situations that you can relate to.

This is not the case anymore.

Given that we have both grown up now (you: age 20, I'm 21), the squeaky clean youthful image we all want to let go of in our twenties is normal. It makes perfect sense. With all things in life, we want to show our maturation and express rebellion to picture-perfect perceptions. But perhaps your recent direction is not only disrespectful and ignorant, but also racially insensitive.

Lately, I can't help but hear about your recent fetish for "twerking" and your new-found interest in showcasing it for the likes of rapper Juicy J while performing his street rap anthem entitled "Bandz Will Make Her Dance."

Has Miley Cyrus gone hip-hop? I first wondered. But perhaps you took it too far.

"I want urban, I just want something that just feels black," you were said to have told hit songwriting brothers Timothy and Theron Thomas for your new racy song "We Can't Stop." And to take it a step further, you express what "feels black" in the music video to the song as a portrayal of you "twerking" (rather badly if you are actually trying to master the craft) with a group of black women enticing you on.

So I guess you were referring to the "homegirls with the big butts, shaking it like we're at a strip club" during that clip. I also take it that in addition to the tatted black guy with the gold chain in the back with you wearing your custom made grill... you now feel a temporary sense of blackness from that as well?

Go take a seat, or better yet, take a course on race, Ms. Cyrus.

In case you were not aware, artists like you continue to contribute to an ever growing problem in the entertainment industry that I like to call "manufacturing race." Often low-key and subtle, but never appropriate, individuals such as you consider using racial stereotypes as a way of accessorizing a new look or change in self image. Don't believe me, just ask Ke$ha.

It is one of the most microaggressive and disrespectful ways of implying, "Hey, I want to act out of character... let's mimic the perception of this group of people." To you, feeling "black" is a way to act like the white girl that you feel you obviously can't be which is problematic within itself.

Your totally off-putting interpretation of what "feels black" is very narrow-minded in scope. In your case, shaking your backside like a stripper makes you feel like you have embraced what it feels like to be black in America. Or did you feel that the gold grill in your mouth and the gangsta like posture at the end of your music video make you feel somewhat connected to a specific "urban" feel you were trying to portray?

Ms. Cyrus, if you have infatuations with acting like a thug or dancing like a stripper that is fine... but with all due respect, don't make such a correlation of it to any race.

Stop associating your fixation for "twerking" as a chance to feel black to your millions of white, Asian, and other non-black fans that don't have the luxury to hide under the veil of your wealthy privilege and bigotry. Stop capitalizing off of racial stereotypes as a way to shape your image, how about just be your own damn self and embrace that. And stop perpetuating the constant industrial disgust of black exploitation in the sake of entertainment.

You never have been nor ever will be about that life, Ms. Cyrus.

What "feels black" is as versatile and subjective as the number of outfits, hairstyles, and jewels you use to cover up your identity, Miley Cyrus. It ranges in the empowerment that comes from overcoming many racial minstrel based stunts that is stigmatized in your banter of twerking and gold chains, to the pain that is felt when watching your music video in 2013 continue it.

Blackness is not a trend or a fad; it is the connection between a group of people bounded by a heritage that your ancestry has had a historical role in negatively impacting. You won't ever desire what that "feels" like, nor would I encourage you to.

At the end of the day, being young and artistically rebellious is understandable. No one wants to hold on to the same image forever, but that doesn't mean offensively perpetuating stereotypes about a particular race of people.

I know that in your lead single to this new album of yours (that I won't be buying, obviously) you declare "we can't stop... and we won't stop." But in matters related to the disrespect of my culture and race, I'm going to request that you do so immediately.

Sincerely,

Ernest Owens

Someone who is no longer a fan of Miley (trying to feel black) Cyrus

Do you all agree or do you think he's just being sensitive?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think certain ppl look at being black as something that's "cool" and "hip". They want what they see in the rap videos but they don't want the discrimination and struggles that come with being black... if that makes any sense.

I feel that what separates the Miley's from the Justin Timberlake's/Robin Thicke's is that Miley's feels forced. Justin stated many times that he looks up to soul singers and you can definitely tell in his music. Just a few years ago Miley said she never heard a Jay Z song in her life and now she's twerking on stage with Juicy J. That just seems kind of odd. I'm not judging or anything. Just giving my opinion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's be real, what she is emulating is "black." It's not all black people, but grills, twerking, etc comes from various groups within black culture.

Does she look ridiculous? Yes. Is it forced? Yes. But she is an aging teen pop star with not a lot to say and no unique sense of self other than to rebel against her former image. At least when Christina got "dirrty" she was still making good music and had the talent, presence and conviction to back it up. I guess it didn't hurt that she was half Latina too :shifty:

So I agree, Miley, you can stop, and you should stop :sigh:

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's be real, what she is emulating is "black." It's not all black people, but grills, twerking, etc comes from various groups within black culture.

Does she look ridiculous? Yes. Is it forced? Yes. But she is an aging teen pop star with not a lot to say and no unique sense of self other than to rebel against her former image. At least when Christina got "dirrty" she was still making good music and had the talent, presence and conviction to back it up. I guess it didn't hurt that she was half Latina too :shifty:

So I agree, Miley, you can stop, and you should stop :sigh:

And X-Tina showed an appreciation for black soul singers early on in her career so it wasn't necessarily forced lol!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's be real, what she is emulating is "black." It's not all black people, but grills, twerking, etc comes from various groups within black culture.

Does she look ridiculous? Yes. Is it forced? Yes. But she is an aging teen pop star with not a lot to say and no unique sense of self other than to rebel against her former image. At least when Christina got "dirrty" she was still making good music and had the talent, presence and conviction to back it up. I guess it didn't hurt that she was half Latina too :shifty:

So I agree, Miley, you can stop, and you should stop :sigh:

kp4.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think certain ppl look at being black as something that's "cool" and "hip". They want what they see in the rap videos but they don't want the discrimination and struggles that come with being black... if that makes any sense.

I feel that what separates the Miley's from the Justin Timberlake's/Robin Thicke's is that Miley's feels forced. Justin stated many times that he looks up to soul singers and you can definitely tell in his music. Just a few years ago Miley said she never heard a Jay Z song in her life and now she's twerking on stage with Juicy J. That just seems kind of odd. I'm not judging or anything. Just giving my opinion.

I was with you up until he who should not be mentioned

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...