Jump to content

Whitney Vrs Janet Who Has Had A Greater Impact..More Successful Or More Respected


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 189
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Ain't nobody here for Whitney and her over shipped albums. Why is The Bodyguard 17x platinum with only 11 million scanned and 1.3 million at BMG. Is the other 5 million copies collecting dust on the s

Whitney stans must be on that Whitney if they think her impact outweighs Janet's. The fact that Whitney has employed things Janet has done into her career is proof of who has had the bigger impact.

This was about overall IMPACT.  Janet wins this one, hands down.  There are people out here still sampling her songs, still doing her iconic dance routines, still using her performance platform. 

:lol:

Well I don't wanna go there, but Mike is a template.. :lol:

True. Janet's the answer to deep, soul searching questions such as "What's the meaning of life?", "Is there life on other planets?" and so on. Not to mention she's a key element to ancient Egyptian scripts along with page 4 of TV guides. -_-
Link to post
Share on other sites

True. Janet's the answer to deep, soul searching questions such as "What's the meaning of life?", "Is there life on other planets" and so on. Not to mention she's a key element to ancient Egyptian scripts along with page 4 of TV guides. -_-

:lmao::lmao::lmao: Her influence knows no bounds.. She pretty much laid it out in "The Velvet Rope". -_-

Link to post
Share on other sites

.about the statement "why would anyone want a career like a failure" (talking about Janet) FLIP IT, your right WHITNEY'S a failure, she's a punchline. Her reputation is shot to hell and is sitting next to her voice from the 80's and early 90's

Having the greatest voices of your generation, but let a coon destroy it with drugs

vs

Coming out of the shadows of Michael Jackson, and end up with dismal album sales

  • Upvote 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

I have seen our goddess immoralized on the walls of the Egyptian pyramids in the form of the goddess Ma'at and also on the walls of the Taj Mahal. She proceeds every goddess ever to exist, giving birth to the most beautiful of them including Aphrodite herself :wub:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Having the greatest voices of your generation, but let a coon destroy it with drugs

vs

Coming out of the shadows of Michael Jackson, and end up with dismal album sales

Not to mention Janet being the prototype of a HUGELY successful tripple threat (somethin even MJ didnt do)

And putting the one with the voice to work trying to learn dance moves so she can compete, yet end up failing misrebly.....

tumblr_ln9x3yhxLt1qihn7io1_500.gif....... enough said

Link to post
Share on other sites

�show me receipts of 5 different artists praising Whitney for something other than her voice.

Beyonce, Britney, GaGa, Michael himself AND Usher And then some, has ALL praised Whitney for not only her voice, but contributions to chart success and a successful film career. Whitney is the blueprint of an artist who has successes from her first album unlike Janet:

take several seats!

Oh, and although Janet may have had better videos, it was Whitney's HWIK that helped break down racial barriers on MTV and help made history! Go play in traffic!

And I think you want to stop now before I SERVE you again and make you look the fool you already ARE!

" show me a video of Michael doing anything remotely close to the videos of the janet. era."

they posted thriller

Link to post
Share on other sites

SOMEBDOY BETTER GET THOSE SNIFFY STANS................

AGAIN, with the "Janet was brought out or dropped from her label" SOMEONE WITH A ACTIVE ACCOUNT THERE TELL THAT IDIOT TO SHOW YOU THE RECIPTS FOR THAT CLAIM!!!!

That idiot said "Whitney has all her problems but that never happend to her" Never happend to Janet either, stupid. Janet was never booted from performing on the Oscars tho, has Whitney ever been? (uh huh hehehe)

I dont like it when people lie about ma baby :flipoff:

Link to post
Share on other sites

one of you need to join ... please..it difficult doing all this by myself ...out numbered

I cant, I REALLY wish I could but.....when I go innnnnnn on another artist fan that disses Janet.............theres trouble, I mean I dont want to even get into my youtube history but lets just say I WILL NOT STOP, and it becomes really bad for me because I LIVE on the edge, planning my responses to their attacks, if Im not at my (or any) computer Im constantly counting the minutes, and thinking about what their response is gonna be. And it just gets really ugly and drawn out

Hell after that LaToya fan REALLLLLY tried me last month, I been trying to get back to not doing that (I've went a entire year in a argument EVERY day on 1 youtube video "Janet vs. Beyonce" my lowest moment). So I think itd be best if I just helped you guys out from over here.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I cant, I REALLY wish I could but.....when I go innnnnnn on another artist fan that disses Janet.............theres trouble, I mean I dont want to even get into my youtube history but lets just say I WILL NOT STOP, and it becomes really bad for me because I LIVE on the edge, planning my responses to their attacks, if Im not at my (or any) computer Im constantly counting the minutes, and thinking about what their response is gonna be. And it just gets really ugly and drawn out

Hell after that LaToya fan REALLLLLY tried me last month, I been trying to get back to not doing that (I've went a entire year in a argument EVERY day on 1 youtube video "Janet vs. Beyonce" my lowest moment). So I think itd be best if I just helped you guys out from over here.

whoaaa

Link to post
Share on other sites

whoaaa

YUP, literally if defending Janet over other artist was a hourly job, within the last 3 yrs, I'd be a VERY rich man, and that is no exageration, and Im not proud of it either lol, I wasted ALOT of time, I've given myself MIGRAINES thinking about "what to say next", "what if they say this", "why didnt I say that" "I should also include", "what's he gonna say". I've gone 3 days without sleep with a coffee pot next to my computer over that Janet vs. Beyonce argument.

When I go in, I dont leave, I have to be almost carried out lol.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I just realized I have an account on that forum... :lol:

It's been YEARS since I used it though. Should I head over and do the most. :shifty::whistle:

Reyna here is a link to that forum (specifically that topic)

http://classicwhitney.yuku.com/topic/7991/Who-has-made-the-greater-impact-Mariah-or-Janet?page=15

I say you should :shifty::wink:

Thanks, babe! ^_^

Link to post
Share on other sites
Beyonce, Britney, GaGa, Michael himself AND Usher And then some, has ALL praised Whitney for not only her voice, but contributions to chart success and a successful film career. Whitney is the blueprint of an artist who has successes from her first album unlike Janet:

Where are the RECEIPTS!? I'm not here for these unsupported claims.

Oh, and although Janet may have had better videos, it was Whitney's HWIK that helped break down racial barriers on MTV and help made history!

Lies and tomfoolery. MTV started out as a Rock station and only catered to Rock artists. Blacks such as Donna Summer, Tina Turner, Eddie Grant, and even the non-Rock group Music Youth were among the first Black acts to get steady rotation on MTV, not Whitney. Michael later got steady rotation in 1983 because his label threatened to pull all their videos off MTV if they didn't play his videos. "How Will I Know" didn't do shit.

" show me a video of Michael doing anything remotely close to the videos of the janet. era."

they posted thriller

:fail:

Link to post
Share on other sites
idrag4mj please your trying to bring other artists beating Whitney's records. Please everybody knows Mariah is the solo artist with most number 1s nobody is denying that. Janet had not sold as much as Whitney won as many awards influence as many or had as many number 1 hits get over it. Dark Side Of The Moon you idiot was released before 90s the person said biggest selling of the 90s damn wake up. Would you like more of a beating?

It's nice and all to name all of these sales achievements, but what does having a entire show dedicated to them being a icon mean or signify? Was Janet the FIRST artist to have that done? Nope. So.....

Whitney scoring a consecutive seven #1s is important because it signified something. Here was a black pop female artist outdoing white male rock bands on the charts. Whitney being the first female to debut at #1 on the album charts is important. Here

It's nice and all to list achievements, but if they don't mean anything, who cares? No one gives a damn if you're the best selling artist in Uzbekistan. No one cares if you sold out 80 concerts in 10 seconds in Czechoslovakia. Unless they signify something, it's better to leave them out.

Whitneyluva wrote:

What's the big deal about the Icon show, that honor doesn't even exist anymore? I mean I love hearing all these facts about Janet bc i'm a fan but for every Janet record, there is a Whitney record as well and more. As much as I love Janet she just isn't bigger than Whitney sorry. People don't even really care about Janet like that anymore, truth is they both are rebuilding their careers.

So True!!!!

Of the Elite5(Madonna, Whitney, Mariah, Janet, Celine) Janet is the less successful one..

Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't see why you're still going at it with them, because they're contradicting themselves. They tried to mention about you (or whoever) bringing up other artists that done better than Britney yet they used Madonna to downplay Janet. They tried to mention they don't care about artists having success in one place, but yet they brought up BoA who's only had real success in Japan (she has 2-3 songs that charted here in the States but her album didn't sell). And finally they say that they're both rebuilding their careers...Janet can, Whitney can't.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

Announcements


×
×
  • Create New...