bu. Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 Does anyone have stats for TLC/Destiny's Child and Spice Girls? Who is the real best selling girl group of all time? On the X Factor someone called in criticising a judge for saying Little Mix (a girl group on the show) have no lead singer and the caller said 'Spice Girls who are the worlds best selling female group' and you could hear Kelly quietly in the background saying "Oh Really.... Slow down....we sold more. we sold more." and now theres a huge debate on digital spy over who sold more. My instincts say Spice Girls did but they're saying DC sold 40million WW which seems too low when they said Kelly has sold 80million records WW (Which obviously includes DC sales). Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TwistedElegance™ Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 *waits for Austin's reply* Viewers can call in to X Factor over there? I love that idea. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Idrag4mj Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 Lol at kelly grabbing onto the stats for her dear life i think Spice girl sold more though Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bu. Posted December 6, 2011 Author Share Posted December 6, 2011 waits for Austin's reply Viewers can call in to X Factor over there? I love that idea. We have a side-show called 'Xtra Factor' which airs straight after. It's basically where everyone discusses the show beforehand and you talk to the judges and the contestants to see how they feel after performing etc. I know Austin has stats so hopefully he'll be here soon . I know DC might not be the best selling but I know thye've sold way more than 40million when Bey was singing 50 million during Survivor SEVEN years ago Lol at kelly grabbing onto the stats for her dear life i think Spice girl sold more though I don't even know if she said it because she muttered something really quietly . I do think Spice Girls sold more too but I'm sure DC outsold TLC. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
King Baby Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 The Dixie Chicks need to be added too. TLC is the best selling in the states though. DC3's sales are inflated due to solo projects. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Escapade Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 Spice Girls>>> They slayed so much in so little time Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Reyna ♔ Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 I think Spice Girls have sold 65-75 million but that's a guess Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TwistedElegance™ Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 We have a side-show called 'Xtra Factor' which airs straight after. It's basically where everyone discusses the show beforehand and you talk to the judges and the contestants to see how they feel after performing etc. I know Austin has stats so hopefully he'll be here soon . I know DC might not be the best selling but I know thye've sold way more than 40million when Bey was singing 50 million during Survivor SEVEN years ago Actually come to think of it we had Xtra Factor during last season and it flopped. They didn't bring it back this year. Some stats include album sales as well as singles. All I know is I'm a huge fan of the big 3. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
King Baby Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 Actually come to think of it we had Xtra Factor during last season and it flopped. They didn't bring it back this year. Some stats include album sales as well as singles. All I know is I'm a huge fan of the big 3. TLC is all that matters. These other girls you speak of are so not a factor. The best girl groups ever go... 1. TLC 2. The Supremes 3. Salt & Pepa Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
janetDAYZ Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 I told y'all this SAME topic comes up EVERY week ... :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: Same ppl debating...same numbers thrown out there. But I can guarantee DC aint outsold no damn Spice Girls ..Kelly SIT DOWN. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bu. Posted December 6, 2011 Author Share Posted December 6, 2011 Actually come to think of it we had Xtra Factor during last season and it flopped. They didn't bring it back this year. Some stats include album sales as well as singles. All I know is I'm a huge fan of the big 3. It's a shame it flopped ...I love it. I think it's a great way to get to know the contestants and what goes on behind the judges decisions in more detail. I told y'all this SAME topic comes up EVERY week ... :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: Same ppl debating...same numbers thrown out there. But I can guarantee DC aint outsold no damn Spice Girls ..Kelly SIT DOWN. It actually does. I did hit search but there was too much shit to go through PS I'm being attacked for saying TLC didn't write their lyrics. I thought they didn't Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
janetDAYZ Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 We have a side-show called 'Xtra Factor' which airs straight after. It's basically where everyone discusses the show beforehand and you talk to the judges and the contestants to see how they feel after performing etc. I know Austin has stats so hopefully he'll be here soon . I know DC might not be the best selling but I know thye've sold way more than 40million when Bey was singing 50 million during Survivor SEVEN years ago I don't even know if she said it because she muttered something really quietly . I do think Spice Girls sold more too but I'm sure DC outsold TLC. Only because they put out more projects than TLC. If you match them album for album..TLC sold more Ooooh On The TLC Tip >>>>> Destiny's Child CrazySexyCool >>>>> Writing's Ont The Wall Fanmail >>>>> Survivor 3D <<<<<< Destiny's Fulfilled DC only had ONE album that sold more...but they have an edge in overall sales because they released greatest hits and xmas albums. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
janetDAYZ Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 It's a shame it flopped ...I love it. I think it's a great way to get to know the contestants and what goes on behind the judges decisions in more detail. It actually does. I did hit search but there was too much shit to go through PS I'm being attacked for saying TLC didn't write their lyrics. I thought they didn't They didn't write. Left eye wrote all her shit but T-Boz only wrote one or two songs..and Chilli..I dont know if that bitch ever picked up a pen. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
King Baby Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 Only because they put out more projects than TLC. If you match them album for album..TLC sold more Ooooh On The TLC Tip >>>>> Destiny's Child CrazySexyCool >>>>> Writing's Ont The Wall Fanmail >>>>> Survivor 3D <<<<<< Destiny's Fulfilled DC only had ONE album that sold more...but they have an edge in overall sales because they released greatest hits and xmas albums. This^ Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CalQuin Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 This^ Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
King Baby Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mr. Wonder Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 Globally: Spice Girls - 75 million Destiny's Child - 60 million TLC - 50 million. As for the US: Destiny's Child ranks second among groups featuring all female members, with album sales of 16,985,000. TLC places third in the category with 15,567,000 albums sold. One other all-female act places among SoundScan's 150 top-selling acts. Spice Girls hold the No. 145 spot with album sales of 11,976,000. http://www.billboard.com/column/chartbeat/ask-billboard-kylie-fever-1004104865.story#/column/chartbeat/ask-billboard-kylie-fever-1004104865.story Get over the fact that DC has outsold TLC. Even when you do the estimations, DC still comes out on top: Oooooh…On The TLC Tip (1992) USA : 4.300.000 Canada : 250.000 Estimation Mondiale : 5.000.000 CrazySexyCool (1994) USA : 11.300.000 Canada : 850.000 Australie : 160.000 Japon : 250.000 Europe : 1.640.000 - UK : 650.000 - Allemagne : 350.000 - France : 50.000 - Pays-Bas : 120.000 (#5 (61)) - Suède : 70.000 (#11 (29)) - Suisse : 50.000 (#10 (24)) - Finlande : 5.000 (#37 (3)) - Autriche : 30.000 (#16 (16)) Estimation Mondiale : 14.800.000 Fanmail (1999) USA : 6.400.000 Canada : 425.000 Australie : 100.000 Nouvelle-Zélande : 25.000 Japon : 1.000.000 Corée Du Sud : 100.000 Europe : 1.810.000 - UK : 650.000 - Allemagne : 350.000 - France : 185.000 - Italie : 40.000 - Pays-Bas : 100.000 (#9 (50)) - Suède : 60.000 (#16 (34)) - Suisse : 50.000 (#11 (37)) - Finlande : 10.000 (#26 (10)) - Autriche : 30.000 (#17 (20)) Estimation Mondiale : 11.300.000 3D (2002) USA : 1.100.000 Japon : 350.000 Corée Du Sud : 40.000 Europe : 120.000 - UK : 40.000 - Allemagne : 20.000 - France : 10.000 - Pays-Bas : #62 (2) - Suisse : #47 (8) Estimation Mondiale : 1.900.000 + 600.000 pour Now and Forever...TLC - The Hits. Ventes Totales Mondiales : 33.600.000 albums vendus. Destiny's Child (1998) : USA : 1.200.000 Canada : 225.000 Brésil : 25.000 UK : 100.000 Pays-Bas : 30.000 Estimations Mondiales : 2.000.000 The Writing's On The Wall (1999) : USA : 8.200.000 Canada : 600.000 Brésil : 50.000 ? Australie : 225.000 Japon : 200.000 Europe : 2.490.000 - UK : 1.100.000 - France : 275.000 - Allemagne : 300.000 - Italie : 40.000 - Espagne : 40.000 - Suède : 50.000 - Suisse : 45.000 - Autriche : 20.000 - Pays-Bas : 200.000 - Norvège : 30.000 - Danemark : 30.000 Estimations Mondiales : 12.300.000 Survivor (2001) : USA : 5.200.000 Canada : 425.000 Brésil : 125.000 Australie : 200.000 Japon : 400.000 Corée : 28.700 Europe : 2.990.000 - UK : 1.100.000 - France : 275.000 - Allemagne : 425.000 - Italie : 120.000 - Espagne : 125.000 - Suède : 100.000 - Pays-Bas : 200.000 - Autriche : 40.000 - Finlande : 33.751 - Suisse : 75.000 - Norvège : 30.000 - Pologne : 50.000 - Danemark : 30.000 Estimations Mondiales : 10.100.000 8 Days Of Christmas (2001) : USA : 700.000 Canada : 50.000 Japon : 75.000 Corée : 9.238 Pays-Bas : 20.000 Allemagne : 20.000 Estimations Mondiales : 1.100.000 This Is The Remix (2002) : USA : 150.000 Japon : 25.000 Corée : 8.692 UK : 30.000 Allemagne : 30.000 Pays-Bas : 10.000 Estimations Mondiales : 400.000 Destiny Fulfilled (2004) : USA : 3.300.000 Canada : 150.000 Brésil : 25.000 Australie : 100.000 Japon : 750.000 Corée : 6.140 Europe : 1.370.000 - UK : 625.000 - Allemagne : 200.000 - France : 125.000 - Italie : 30.000 - Espagne : 50.000 - Pays-Bas : 45.000 - Suède : 15.000 - Suisse : 35.000 - Autriche : 15.000 Estimations Mondiales : 6.500.000 #1's (2005) : USA : 1.300.000 Canada : 125.000 Argentine : 20.000 Brésil : 25.000 Australie : 100.000 Japon : 750.000 Europe : 510.000 - UK : 225.000 - Allemagne : 50.000 - France : 75.000 - Italie : 20.000 - Pays-Bas : 15.000 - Espagne : 15.000 - Suède : 5.000 - Suisse : 15.000 - Autriche : 5.000 Estimations Mondiales : 3.400.000 Ventes totales mondiales : 35.800.000 albums vendus. Spice (1996) USA : 7.700.000 Canada : 1.400.000 Brésil : 525.000 Mexique : 200.000 Argentine : 60.000 Chili : 40.000 Venezuela : 20.000 Colombie : 50.000 Australie : 420.000 Nouvelle-Zélande : 60.000 Japon : 800.000 Singapour : 60.000 Philippines : 160.000 Taiwan : 200.000 Thailande : 200.000 Malaisie : 75.000 Hong Kong : 40.000 Indonésie : 50.000 Inde : 20.000 Corée du Sud : 200.000 Arabie Saoudite : 80.000 Israel : 20.000 Afrique du Sud : 50.000 Turquie : 20.000 Europe : 9.370.000 - UK : 3.300.000 - Allemagne : 875.000 - France : 1.050.000 - Italie : 620.000 - Espagne : 1.025.000 - Pays-Bas : 380.000 - Suisse : 110.000 - Suède : 300.000 - Autriche : 75.000 - Norvège : 80.000 - Finlande : 76.400 - Pologne : 200.000 - Belgique : 150.000 Estimation Mondiale : 22.800.000 Spice World (1997) USA : 4.400.000 Canada : 1.200.000 Brésil : 425.000 Mexique : 150.000 Australie : 420.000 Nouvelle-Zélande : 45.000 Japon : 400.000 Europe : 5.340.000 - UK : 1.800.000 - Allemagne : 600.000 - France : 620.000 - Italie : 520.000 - Espagne : 250.000 - Pays-Bas : 185.000 - Suisse : 110.000 - Suède : 170.000 - Autriche : 65.000 - Norvège : 40.000 - Finlande : 92.200 - Pologne : 200.000 - Belgique : 100.000 Estimation Mondiale : 14.400.000 Forever (2000) USA : 250.000 Canada : 75.000 Brésil : 40.000 Japon : 80.000 Corée Du Sud : 15.000 Europe : 600.000 - UK : 300.000 - Allemagne : 65.000 - France : 15.000 - Espagne : 20.000 - Italie : 45.000 - Pays-Bas : 15.000 - Suède : 10.000 - Suisse : 15.000 - Autriche : 10.000 - Finlande : 5.000 Estimation Mondiale : 1.200.000 Greatest Hits (2007) Estimation Mondiale : 1.300.000 Ventes Totales Mondiales : 39.700.000 albums vendus. Spice Girls > Destiny's Child > TLC GET. OVER. IT. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
janetDAYZ Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 The cards were shuffled,dealt and we're dealing with it. We get it! No different than Madonna and Mariah selling more than Janet since they've had MORe releases than her. You even said yourself had Janet done a few fluff albums in between her huge releases in the 90s..her sales would have been even higher and closer to her contemps. This is no different. DC has 3 extra projects on TLC and there is only a 2 million difference in their total sales...???? DEAD @ you acting as if DC was bigger and more popular when matching the sales of each album says something COMPLETELY different. :lmao: Dc only won the DF vs 3D round! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mr. Wonder Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 The cards were shuffled,dealt and we're dealing with it. We get it! No different than Madonna and Mariah selling more than Janet since they've had MORe releases than her. You even said yourself had Janet done a few fluff albums in between her huge releases in the 90s..her sales would have been even higher and closer to her contemps. This is no different. DC has 3 extra projects on TLC and there is only a 2 million difference in their total sales...???? DEAD @ you acting as if DC was bigger and more popular when matching the sales of each album says something COMPLETELY different. :lmao: Dc only won the DF vs 3D round! T4P! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Illi Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 I think we can all agree that they shat for the female vocal groups, because before them, no girl group was doing much after the Supremes. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
janetDAYZ Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 No rebuttal? :o That's A FIRST :lmao: There's nothing. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Escapade Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 Globally: Spice Girls - 75 million Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bu. Posted December 6, 2011 Author Share Posted December 6, 2011 Austin can you provide a writing credit list for TLC and DC please? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
vaquero Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 even though I am a HUGE Spice Girls fan all of these groups have made an everlasting impression in pop culture history they will never be denied! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
janetDAYZ Posted December 6, 2011 Share Posted December 6, 2011 Austin can you provide a writing credit list for TLC and DC please? How bout we get Spice Girls writing credits too..why leave them out? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.